Impact Windows vs Hurricane Shutters in Lauderhill, FL

Every visit starts with

Free in-home measure and quote - PGT, CGI and CWS impact lines compared on your actual openings, style by style

Styles & brands we work with

‹

Single hungDouble hungHorizontal roller

Sliding glass doors

Impact garage doorsPGTCGI

›

Before & after – our own jobs

‹

BeforeAfter

BeforeAfter

BeforeAfter

›

For Most Lauderhill Homes, Impact Windows Beat Hurricane Shutters. Here’s the Honest Math.

Impact windows are the better long-term investment for most Lauderhill homeowners, but hurricane shutters still make sense in a narrow set of circumstances: a house you’re selling within two years, a budget ceiling that simply won’t move, or a condo board that won’t approve window replacement. If you plan to stay in your home past 2030 and your current windows are original to the house, impact windows typically pay for themselves through insurance premium reductions alone. Call (850) 303-7739 and we’ll run the actual numbers for your block.

We’ve been setting glass in Broward County since the early 1990s, and Dale Kessler, our owner, grew up off Oakland Park Boulevard watching his father reglaze windows for neighbors who couldn’t afford a service call. The comparison people ask about most isn’t theoretical. It’s a Lauderhill homeowner standing in a living room with 1968 jalousie windows, holding a renewal notice from an insurer that just added a $4,100 wind mitigation surcharge, trying to decide whether shutters are enough. That’s the question this page answers.

Key Takeaways

• Impact windows raise your home’s resale value and lower insurance costs; shutters do neither. Shutters only reduce a premium surcharge. Impact windows eliminate the underlying reason for it.
• Shutters have no “on” position when you’re not home. A storm that hits while you’re visiting family in Orlando leaves the house fully exposed.
• Broward County’s HVHZ code makes shutters a temporary compliance patch, not a permanent solution. Insurers know the difference and price accordingly.
• For Lauderhill’s 1960s and 1970s CBS homes, impact windows solve three problems at once: wind protection, failed seals, and energy loss from single-pane aluminum frames.

The Lauderhill Reality Most Comparison Articles Skip

Lauderhill sits entirely inside Broward County’s High-Velocity Hurricane Zone. That’s not a coastal technicality. Every window and door replacement in this city must carry Miami-Dade or Florida product approval for impact resistance, a standard stricter than almost anywhere else in the country. When you read a generic article that says “impact windows and shutters both protect your home,” it’s written for someone who doesn’t live under HVHZ code. In Lauderhill, shutters meet the requirement on paper for wind mitigation credits. Impact windows meet the requirement and fix the underlying condition insurers are actually looking at.

We have a page that covers impact windows and doors in Lauderhill in depth. What that page doesn’t spell out is the honest comparison between your two main options, which is what you’re weighing right now. So let’s make the comparison in plain terms.

Impact Windows vs Hurricane Shutters: A Straight Comparison

Here’s the framework we walk customers through on site visits. Not a sales pitch. Just the categories that matter most when you’re in a 1972 CBS ranch on NW 19th Street with original aluminum sliding windows.

If you read that table and think shutters sound reasonable because the up-front number is lower, we understand. Budgets are real. But remember what the insurer is actually looking at. A home with shutters has a wind protection system that depends on human deployment. A home with impact windows has permanent protection baked into the building envelope. Actuaries price those two situations very differently.

Where Shutters Still Make Sense in Lauderhill

We’re not here to talk anyone out of a sound decision. There are three situations where shutters are genuinely the right call:

1. You’re selling within 24 months. Impact windows are an investment that pays back over time through insurance savings, energy savings, and resale value. If you won’t be in the house to capture that, don’t make the capital outlay.
2. A condo association blocks window replacement. Some buildings in Century Village Lauderhill and other mid-rise communities have architectural review boards that restrict exterior changes. Shutters may be your only compliant path to wind mitigation credits.
3. Your windows are under 10 years old and perform well. If a previous owner already replaced the glass, adding hurricane shutters can be a reasonable stopgap until the windows themselves need addressing.

Outside those three scenarios, we usually tell Lauderhill homeowners the truth: impact windows are the last window and door purchase you’ll make on this house. Shutters are a purchase you’ll make and then eventually replace with the thing you should have bought first.

What We See in Lauderhill’s Older Homes

Lauderhill’s core housing stock is 1960s and 1970s CBS construction: ranch homes and mid-rise condos with single-pane aluminum jalousie, awning, or sliding windows set directly into concrete block. The heat, humidity, and UV exposure here don’t just age glass. Aluminum frames oxidize and pit within a decade. Glazing seals fail. Weatherstripping hardens and cracks. Long before any storm threatens, these windows are leaking air you’re paying to cool.

Jalousie windows especially are a problem we see on nearly every other house when we canvas the blocks around Inverrary. They’re effectively prohibited in new HVHZ construction because there’s no way to make a louvered glass opening meet impact standards. Local insurers specifically flag them as uninsurable openings. If you have jalousies anywhere in your house right now, shutters are a bandage. The openings themselves need to go.

When we replace jalousies with impact-rated fixed or casement windows from manufacturers like CWS, ES Windows, or ECO Window Systems, the difference is immediate. The house holds temperature. The street noise drops. The insurance inspection comes back clean. That’s the outcome we’re after.

How We Price and Install Impact Windows

TruePane is not the low bid in the room, and we don’t try to be. What we do is show you manufacturer lines side by side on paper, so you see exactly what you’re paying for and why. If the spec sheet doesn’t back it up, we don’t say it. CGI and CWS windows differ in frame construction, glass package, hardware, and warranty terms. You should know all of it before you sign anything.

Every job carries the Done Right Promise backed by The Keystone Standard: both manufacturer warranty layers are registered in writing, with durations stated, before our truck leaves your driveway. No paperwork fights. No arguing. If the pane is not true, the job is not done. That’s not a slogan, it’s the founding rule Dale Kessler keeps on the whiteboard, and it’s been the standard since 2008 of community service in Broward County.

You’ll get a live person when you call, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Not a voicemail tree. Not a call center in another state. A background-checked, uniformed technician will measure every opening twice, because a wrong measurement on a CBS wall is an expensive mistake neither of us wants. Most jobs are completed in a single visit, and you get a senior or veteran discount on top of honest, upfront pricing.

FAQs